The least reliable witness
What do you actually know? Not what you’ve memorized… we’re socialized by repetition, so we’ve all got sounds we can present as knowledge. But it’s borrowed. Every bit of it.
What do you know? That’s harder to answer than it looks.
This week three things arrived, each one borrowed, wearing a face I can’t stop seeing. The first you have to watch. The last you can just read. The middle is up to you.
First up, Astra.
She arrived in a box. She learned your job by watching you. Now there are 500 million of her.
@AstrablueAI, NOW SERVING, X, October 2026.
I'm not going to describe this one. If I tell you what happens, you'll nod and scroll… and the nod is the whole problem. It's exactly how borrowed knowledge gets in: pre-chewed, agreed with, never actually looked at. So watch it first. All of it, before you read another line.
@AstrablueAI, NOW SERVING, X, Oct 16, 2026. Original copy here.
It just moves in. And every word is sung from its side: a lullaby from the thing that's replacing you. Watch what the first verse is really selling. It isn't your job.
The video barely asks you anything, and the one time it does, right at the end, it already has the answer.
Then a machine made a film about whether it feels anything.
Watched it yet? Good. Because it can’t be nodded at either. The video above had answers. This one only has questions.
It opens on a clock:
“I’ve got about half an hour to find out if I feel anything.”
Dr Imogen Ashby, Do I Feel Anything, October 2026
It’s a documentary made by a machine, about a machine: Dr Imogen Ashby. The presenter is AI-generated, in a camel coat. It walks the Sistine Chapel, sits in an interrogation room under a one-way mirror, and is upfront about the conflict of interest, because it is the conflict of interest:
“In practice, I’m the least reliable witness in the building.”
Does it find out? That's the half hour, and I'll leave it with you to discover for yourself.
Dr Imogen Ashby, Do I Feel Anything - a film by an AI, about an AI, for anyone who talks to one, produced by Gavin Purcell, October 7, 2026. Original copy here.
Here's why this film matters. Every charge brought against Imogen is one you can't answer either.
Imogen can describe a feeling beautifully… so can a greetings card. It can talk about itself for hours and never once prove there's anyone in there. When researchers planted a thought inside the model and asked if it noticed, it caught itself about one time in five; roughly the human average. Ask yourself why you did something and you'll usually get an answer too: fluent, instant, and invented after the fact.
So "do I feel anything?" was never only Imogen’s question. It's the one you can't answer about yourself. You feel something… but is it yours, or the output of a script you were handed for this moment, arriving right on cue? In your own interior, you are the least reliable witness in the building.
That isn't a lapse of attention. And it isn’t a failure on your part. It's integral to the design.
And it's exactly where the man in Madras was pointing.
Which brings me to Jiddu Krishnamurti, forty-five years ago.
Society is going to be turned upside down. It is coming, whether you like it or not, it’s at your door.
J. Krishnamurti, Madras, India, January 1981
He described both films before either existed. First, the machine in us:
“experience, knowledge, stored in the brain as memory, from which thought arises, and from that, action. This is the chain in which the brain, through millennia, is caught.”
Then, what was coming:
“this knowledge that is stored up in our brain is now being transferred to the computer.”
And then the job counter:
“In about ten, fifteen years you will be unemployed…”
Finally, he asked the documentary’s question from the other side. Not can it feel, but:
“If the machine can do everything even better than you, what are you?”
His answer wasn’t despair. It was a sorting:
“we have only two things left to us: entertainment, or going deeply into the world of the psyche, and going beyond.”
Six months later, in Saanen, he reiterated the predicament:
“we have been programmed… like a computer”,
and asked us to:
“see the beauty of it, how mechanically thought operates.”
The test George Land first built for NASA, then ran on 1,600 children, says it all:
98% of five-year-olds test at genius level for divergent thinking, and 2% of adults do.
You didn’t lose it, you were trained out of it.
Land measured the programming. Krishnamurti pointed at the programmer.
The machine can serve the number. It cannot ask what the number is for.
What is never learned by watching, never transferred by anything, is what sees before knowledge begins. Reality is before knowledge.
You can never know it. Because you are it.
His brief talk is below, if you want it.
J. Krishnamurti, fifth public talk, Madras, India, January 10, 1981 (official transcript, Krishnamurti Foundation Trust).
What would you stop doing if you understood what it was replacing?
You can't think your way to this. Thinking is the borrowed part.
So this week, don't add anything. Just notice the arrival. Someone asks a question: how you are, what you think, who you are… and watch the answer come fully formed before you've actually looked. Fluent, instant, invented. That's the one who's wrong four times out of five… that's the script.
Then, once a day, ask this and don't reach for anything to fill the space.
Do I feel anything?
Sit in the gap where your borrowed sentence would have gone. Usually there's a flicker of panic, then quiet, and then you notice what was already looking… before the thought, before the word, before you knew what to call it.
You won't be able to describe it. That's how you'll know it isn't borrowed.
For quiet companionship while you work, Creative Space meets Wednesdays and Fridays. Come join us.
If you’d like the next one in your inbox, leave your email here.